Few positions in baseball demand as much skill, toughness, and intelligence as catcher — and few players embody all three quite like Will Smith of the Los Angeles Dodgers. Since making his debut, Smith has quietly built a resume that places him among the elite, sparking a legitimate debate: Is Will Smith the best catcher in Major League Baseball?
1. Offensive Numbers That Rival Superstars
When comparing offensive output, Smith’s stats consistently rank near the top among all catchers. Over the past few seasons, he has averaged:
- Batting average: around .270
- On-base percentage: near .360
- Home runs: 20–25 per season
- RBIs: 75–90 annually
In a position historically dominated by defense-first players, Smith’s offensive consistency and power make him stand out. He often ranks alongside or above hitters like Adley Rutschman, J.T. Realmuto, and Sean Murphy in production. The Dodgers rely on him as a middle-of-the-order bat — a rarity for any catcher in MLB.
2. Defensive Growth and Game-Calling Mastery
While his bat gets attention, Smith’s defensive skills have evolved into one of his greatest assets. He’s become a trusted strategist behind the plate, managing one of baseball’s most talented pitching rotations with precision.
- Pitch framing: among the top catchers in metrics and consistency
- Game-calling: praised by teammates like Clayton Kershaw and Walker Buehler
- Blocking and throws: strong, disciplined, and dependable
Smith’s calm and calculated approach has earned the confidence of every pitcher he works with — a hallmark of truly elite catchers.
3. Comparing to the Competition
To answer whether Smith is the best, it’s fair to compare him with other top-tier catchers:
| Player | Strengths | Weaknesses |
|---|---|---|
| Will Smith (Dodgers) | Power, consistency, leadership, game-calling | Slightly below-average pop time |
| Adley Rutschman (Orioles) | Elite defense, plate discipline | Less power output so far |
| J.T. Realmuto (Phillies) | Speed, veteran experience, framing | Declining offensive numbers |
| Sean Murphy (Braves) | Strong defense, power | Less consistent contact |
When viewed side-by-side, Smith offers the most balanced overall package — combining consistent hitting, strong defense, and quiet leadership.
4. Leadership and Intangibles
Catching is as much about mindset as mechanics, and Smith’s personality fits perfectly in the Dodgers’ championship culture. He’s respected, composed, and focused, rarely letting emotions dictate his play. His ability to handle elite pitchers while contributing big hits makes him an invaluable two-way leader.
5. Postseason Proven
Smith has delivered in October, showcasing clutch hitting and steady defensive control under the brightest lights. His ability to handle postseason pressure — especially for a storied franchise like the Dodgers — further strengthens his case as MLB’s best all-around catcher.
Conclusion: The Complete Catcher
While debates will continue between fans of Adley Rutschman, J.T. Realmuto, and others, Will Smith’s total impact — from power hitting to defensive reliability — places him at or near the top of the list. He’s not just a great player for the Dodgers; he’s a model of what the modern catcher should be.
I’m a blogger.